Autism News Beat

An evidence-based resource for journalists

Autism News Beat header image 2
tadalafil uk 25mg viagra online without prescription cialis professional c20 generic viagra price viagra suppliers buy viagra pill online levitra online prescription viagra herbal is generic levitra safe cialis from canada indian generic cialis generic cialis manufacturer tadalafil suppliers viagra super active ingredients buy viagra no prescription buy viagra soft tabs online cialis soft tabs no prescription generic equivalent for viagra cialis super viagra levitra prescribing information tadalafil or cialis levitra online purchase cialis online no prescription genuine viagra sales purchase viagra without a prescription generic cialis forum kamagra tablets prices discount cialis us chewable kamagra generic viagra blue pill 25mg viagra for sale without prescription online viagra sales buy levitra tablets 200 mg viagra levitra for women generic viagra sildenafil citrate viagra soft tabs 100mg viagra soft tabs 100mg order viagra no prescription vardenafil cipla tadalafil for sale order viagra online without a prescription sildenafil citrate soft ordering viagra in canada cheapest viagra super active canadian pharmacy cialis viagra ranbaxy how to get viagra sample generic viagra cheap viagra generic viagra coupons cipla viagra cialis dosage frequency buying viagra without prescription tadalafil 20 mg generic cialis pills buy kamagra paypal tadalafil daily dose manufacturer of cialis sildenafil citrate 100mg reviews cialis splitting is generic cialis available order cheap viagra online cialis 20 mg directions generic viagra without prescription what is levitra 20mg kamagra oral jelly price cialis otc tadalafil generic india viagra to buy online buy cialis generic online natural viagra gnc blue kamagra tadalafil tablets dosage cheap viagra price price of viagra in singapore vardenafil pharmacy cialis in canada oral jelly vardenfil buy cheap levitra viagra 20mg viagra without a rx cheap kamagra jelly levitra with no prescription original viagra online liquid sildenafil citrate generic viagra professional viagra drug prices buy viagra spray cialis fast delivery cialis drug buy generic cialis online generic viagra safety generic viagra from india real viagra vs generic viagra cialis australia vardenafil cheap buy kamagra in uk reliable viagra supplier original viagra viagra suppliers in UK retail price of cialis viagra online USA women viagra viagra UK over the counter generic viagra online UK viagra low cost generic viagra 50mg viagra classification buying viagra in australia buy viagra pills where to buy viagra cheap cheap kamagra online uk viagra samples viagra online order cialis 5mg price viagra ingredients cialis dosage recommended tadalafil price no rx viagra buy viagra without a prescription overnight generic kamagra cost of viagra in south africa generic viagra cheap buy cialis online viagra pills for men viagra online prescriptions levitra tab 20mg generic cialis pills levitra from india sildenafil citrate 100mg cialis soft tabs review cialis medicine kamagra for women viagra online order guide viagra gel caps where to buy genuine viagra levitra vardenafil hcl viagra mailing list kamagra tablets online generic cialis pill viagra cost in australia viagra pharmacy cost safe viagra viagra impotence cialis 2.5mg generic viagra 100mg viagra 50mg price buy online viagra brand cialis online viagra mastercard india viagra what is cialis tablets cialis soft tablets sildenafil vs tadalafil indian viagra brands viagra buying online over the counter viagra equivalent purchase viagra online online cialis sales buy levitra without prescription images of viagra vardenafil online buy viagra legally viagra jelly for sale viagra cheapest fast viagra levitra cheapest price sildenafil powder cialis 5mg tablets prescription cialis cialis testimonials cialis women viagra pricing viagra soft tabs information generic viagra toronto viagra UK no prescription viagra shipped for free free viagra sample viagra online canada generic levitra india cheap cialis india cheapest cialis generic non prescription viagra substitute viagra nicknames purchase cialis canada viagra pills for cheap canadian pharmacy cialis generic sildenafil medication generic brands of viagra viagra cheap online get cialis prescription online cialis 10mg or 20mg viagra belfast cialis how often viagra equivalent cialis singapore viagra online US levitra patent levitra dose cialis online order viagra gel tabs buy cialis in canada generic cialis mastercard buy tadalafil in ireland viagra online canada tadalafil professional levitra prescriptions cialis softtabs buy brand viagra sildenafil trade names viagra fast shipping viagra free sample cialis no prescription needed sildenafil tablets cost of cialis in thailand cialis online uk generic viagra purchase viagra vs cialis brand viagra online viagra india cheap viagra in UK natural cialis viagra canada no prescription viagra in canada viagra paypal sildenafil citrate pills viagra cialis levitra compare vardenafil for women viagra next day shipping professional viagra sublingual viagra viagra for women kamagra delivery australia viagra viagra prescribing information levitra prices online viagra order sildenafil sales buy levitra uk sildenafil no prescription kamagra gel cheap generic sildenafil india canada cialis cheap kamagra uk tadalafil sample purchase viagra canada ordering cialis without prescription herbal viagra cartridge buy viagra prescription online canada cialis generic cheap kamagra online uk compare levitra cialis online viagra sale viagra manufacturer coupon viagra brands cialis new zealand buy cialis 5mg viagra female viagra gel uk kamagra 100 chewable tablet buy viagra now online cheap viagra from india vardenafil no prescription online sale viagra viagra prescription needed cialis 50mg cialis professional canada viagra young men cialis without prescription viagra pictures discount levitra online 40 mg cialis levitra online order viagra without prescription uk canadian viagra generic pfizer viagra generic sildenafil india viagra price canada cialis once a day pill viagra street price cialis generic lowest price generic levitra canada viagra alternative new drugs viagra alternatives buy vardenafil otc levitra buy viagra line cialis daily coupon viagra copy buy viagra meds online generic viagra in singapore generic viagra forum viagra cost per pill viagra 100 mg cialis cost per pill tadalafil liquid sildenafil UK online viagra pharmacy buy generic cialis sildenafil suspension viagra drug name buy viagra for women cheapest cialis price cialis mexican pharmacy kamagra sildenafil 100mg viagra price canada cialis pharmacy prices buy viagra online in the UK generic cialis super active where can i buy viagra safely ordering cialis from canada viagra available in india viagra canada pharmacy viagra prescription cost viagra no prescription needed sildenafil 25mg purchase viagra on line viagra drug buy tadalafil without prescription cialis over the counter purchase sildenafil get viagra prescription online sildenafil citrate online viagra edmonton buy cialis no prescription viagra vs levitra vardenafil tablets discount online viagra cialis multiple attempts ordering viagra in canada viagra shops generic viagra tab cheap generic viagra online cialis daily use review cheap tadalafil uk levitra 10 mg tablet free viagra samples online levitra bayer 20 cialis price walmart levitra online purchase where to purchase viagra cialis daily use safe buy viagra online kamagra soft tabs viagra under tongue kamagra oral buy levitra professional viagra pfizer 50 mg buy cialis discount generic viagra soft tabs cheapest cialis uk super kamagra tablets generic sildenafil 100mg kamagra for sale cialis toronto viagra discount prices buy viagra for cheap viagra pills for cheap viagra young men generic viagra overnight cialis drug company order viagra UK viagra online sales viagra retail viagra generic brand purchase viagra UK order sildenafil without prescription cheap viagra without prescription buy cheap kamagra cialis price per pill where to buy real viagra online discount cialis online generic viagra overnight generic viagra cost generic viagra next day delivery natural viagra substitutes cialis no rx sildenafil citrate best price cialis low price cialis price uk buy levitra no prescription buy viagra meds online buy cialis europe tadalafil online viagra tablets price sildenafil tablets 50mg cialis oral viagra trials cialis generic cheap cialis price per pill generic cialis no prescription levitra faq levitra overnight delivery buy tadalafil no prescription cheap viagra jelly average cost of levitra cost of viagra at cvs buy vardenafil hcl 20mg tab buy tadalafil 20mg buy viagra 25 mg cialis cost comparison buy viagra 100mg levitra discount viagra sale cheap viagra 100mg viagra canada online buy viagra next day delivery viagra canadian cheapest sildenafil citrate viagra liquid form over the counter viagra boots buy viagra cheap online generic cialis india viagra indian version when is viagra prescribed kamagra legal viagra prescription UK vardenafil 10 mg can i order cialis online is generic tadalafil safe discount viagra pills viagra medical information cialis vs. viagra buy cialis cheap thailand viagra buy viagra perth cialis prescription cost cheap viagra generic online generic cialis generic viagra usa levitra mexico viagra frequency kamagra wholesale blue pills viagra cheapest viagra generic viagra uk generic cialis paypal vardenafil hcl generic cialis tablets for sale buy online viagra securely female viagra does it work kamagra india cialis online fast shipping price of viagra in mexico tadalafil 10mg buy viagra american express generic levitra pills buy viagra in singapore cost of daily cialis viagra new zealand cheap safe viagra otc sildenafil kamagra oral jelly buy levitra 2.5mg over the counter viagra replacement generic viagra cipla where to buy levitra online viagra order vardenafil drug sildenafil citrate 100mg india buy cialis soft vardenafil patent buy kamagra australia tadalafil soft tabs natural viagra substitutes generic tadalafil uk levitra vardenafil australia viagra 100mg tablets cialis 10 mg daily sildenafil 100 mg tablets viagra wholesale viagra prescription online generic viagra in canada kamagra pills cheap kamagra online cialis online cheap viagra generic cheap where can i buy kamagra in london order viagra from canada viagra indian pharmacy kamagra 100 mg generic levitra tablets tadalafil structure levitra 10mg tablets buy levitra pills buy viagra online UK cialis promise program 5mg tadalafil order cheap viagra online buy viagra safely viagra prescription cost where can i buy viagra safely oral sildenafil viagra without prescription online viagra discount prices viagra canada pharmacy buy kamagra jelly online natural viagra viagra soft tablets buy sildenafil citrate 50 mg cheap kamagra oral jelly buy levitra no prescription where to buy sildenafil citrate viagra delivered overnight cialis package insert levitra for sale cheap generic viagra online how to make liquid cialis buy generic tadalafil original cialis online sample of levitra generic viagra for sale viagra price per pill buy cialis online without a prescription compare viagra cialis levitra green kamagra buy viagra us levitra directions buy sildenafil buy cialis viagra viagra for sale viagra pills 100 mg herbal viagra alternative where to buy viagra tablets kamagra genuine viagra prescriptions 150mg viagra cheapest cialis buying viagra online without prescription cialis pharmacy online order cialis professional buy viagra using paypal buy levitra generic cheap soft viagra cialis pack sample cheapest kamagra online order viagra online without a prescription cheap levitra pills professional cialis online tadalafil generic buy cialis 20mg indian version of cialis buy kamagra gel order levitra without prescription viagra ordering online buying viagra online cialis 20mg effects is generic cialis effective female cialis get cialis online buy generic viagra in australia sildenafil women buy viagra low cost generic cialis uk

Frontline plays what isn’t there

April 29th, 2010 · 17 Comments · Kudos, Narrative

False balance is the scourge of science reporting, and in The Vaccine Wars, we see how it’s possible to represent both sides without misleading viewers. The Frontline documentary, which first aired Tuesday, devotes about 60% of its time to the researchers and experts who are best qualified to speak. That leaves about 22 minutes for vaccine rejectionists to convince viewers how misguided and poorly informed they truly are. It was more than enough.

But what the reality-based community sees as a virtue is also the biggest complaint that anti-vaccine activists have about the show – that writer/producer Jon Palfreman ignored their “experts”, and falsely portrayed the story as scientists versus parents. “Where are the doctors and scientists who support our community and support the idea that vaccines may be a trigger for autism?” opined Jenny McCarthy the very next day in Huffington Post, “In Frontline’s world, they don’t exist.”

McCarthy’s science adviser, Dr. Jay Gordon chimed in: “You interviewed me, you spent hours with Dr. Robert Sears of the deservedly-illustrious Sears family and you spoke to other doctors who support parents in their desire to find out what went wrong and why it’s going wrong and what we might do to prevent this true epidemic.” Gordon reportedly sat at McCarthy’s side during her interview, slightly out of frame. His absence was both poignant and illuminating.

Reading the breathless complaints from McCarthy and others of her angry mob reminded me of something that jazz great Miles Davis once said: “Don’t play what’s there. Play what’s not there.”

With enough practice, most of us can keep a beat or carry a tune, but it takes an artist to play what isn’t there. The silence that bookends a note reveals as much, if not more, than the sound that you hear, the difference between noise and music. For a writer, recognizing what does and does not belong is the difference between stenography and journalism. Only a flack cares about including every voice in equal measure, with no regards for what is being said. To truly inform, some voices are best unheard.

It’s not always about what you put in. It’s also about what you leave out.

Tags:

17 responses so far ↓

  • 1 KWombles // Apr 29, 2010 at 12:57 pm

    Wonderful post. :-)

  • 2 Prometheus // Apr 30, 2010 at 2:46 pm

    Jay Gordon should be thanking the Frontline editors for cutting his interview from their piece. From what I’ve seen, they weren’t likely to let his particular variety of nonsense go unanswered by the real experts. “Dr. Jay” was spared a nationwide prime-time humiliation.

    Of course, he doesn’t see it that way.

    Here’s a helpful tip for the good doctor:

    The press appear to have gotten over their need to present “both sides” equally, as if there was some parity between the data-free ramblings of a general pediatrician and the data-supported opinions of real experts in autism, epidemiology, immunology, toxicology, etc. This appears to be a long-term change – hopefully permanent.

    This might be a good time for “Dr. Jay” to reconsider his high-profile anti-vaccination position; it is likely to come back and bite him on the posterior. When the next measles outbreak kills a bunch of kids, the press may be able to forgive Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey for their “too many, too soon” and “green our vaccines” nonsense, but they will be all over a board-certified pediatrician who discourages the routine vaccination of healthy children.

    Just a hint, “Dr. Jay”. How will you answer the reporters camped on your lawn when they ask you, “So, doctor, what do you think about your advice about vaccines now?”

    You might want to prepare an answer to that question now.

    Prometheus

  • 3 Sullivan // May 1, 2010 at 7:14 am

    But, the vaccine-causation groups are so good at providing balance that they have the moral high ground, right?

    It isn’t like they use the retracted Wakefield paper to help convince parents, while ignoring the Hornig paper that clearly refutes much of Wakefield’s work.

    No, they wouldn’t do that.

    It isn’t like they use the “Rain Mouse” study, but not the MIND Institute study that clearly refutes “Rain Mouse”.

    No, they wouldn’t do that.

    One could go on and on with the attempts at clearly one-sided arguments the vaccine-causation groups depend upon.

    Besides, what is their argument now? That the parents who run the “Parent founded, Parent led” organizations don’t know what they are talking about (as in, they need a coach off screen) or don’t have the credibility to carry off their arguments?

  • 4 Sullivan // May 1, 2010 at 7:17 am

    It is worth noting as well–

    JB Handley and Jenny McCarthy pressured the producers of “The Doctors” TV show to keep any opposing views off the air.

    The hypocrisy of their complaints against Frontline is astounding. Frontline *did* give both sides. Frontline *did* get input from people like Dr. Jay.

  • 5 Harold L Doherty // May 3, 2010 at 9:26 am

    Terrible post. Absolutely terrible.

    I am not an anti-vaxxer. My children have received all recommended vaccine shots. I have not concluded that my son’s Autistic Disorder was triggered or caused by any vaccine but I do question the science which has allegedly “disproved” and “debunked” any vaccine autism connection.

    You mention the usual names but fail to mention Dr. Healy and Dr. Gerberding who have said that comparative autism studies of existing vaccinated and unvaccinated populations could and should be done.

    You also fail to mention Dr. Irva Hertz-Picciotto who has stated that the autism thimerosal studies are flawed and there is a need for stronger science on that issue.

    Autism News Beat as an evidence based resource for journalists? If only.

  • 6 Dedj // May 3, 2010 at 10:46 am

    Again Harold, you fail to provide any form of reasoning as to why:

    The numerous people that disagree with your sources should be ignored.
    The numerous people that your sources disagree with should be ignored.
    Why and how HP’s criticism of the current science is notable, given that several of the studies and study authours recognised and reported weakenesses themselves.

    Until you can do this minimal work, you, Sir, are in no posistion to go around bad mouthing anyone else.

    You still have unanswered concerns over at Respectful Insolence as well as numerous other discussions that you have been in. Your persistant attempts to dodge meeeting the standards of arguementation that you demand of others has been noted, and you are hereby notified that this behaviour is both rude and hypocritical. Your persistant belief that everyone is ignorant and stupid if they disagree with you is certainly not the behaviour one would expect of a ‘award winning’ autism ‘advocate’.

    Nothing you can respond with will change the fact that you come across like a self-referencing, self-righteous pillock. Have a good day, Sir.

  • 7 ANB // May 3, 2010 at 10:52 am

    dedj is right, Harold. Your comments are adding very little if anything to the discussion.

  • 8 Dedj // May 3, 2010 at 11:38 am

    Indeed ANB, Harold not only wrongly assumes people don’t know what he knows (hence why he once told an experienced autism advocate and lay director of an autism charity that he was a ‘do nothing, know nothing’, and once told a autism lecturer who has published ABA research that she ‘knew nothing about ABA’) but he merely repeats what they say without providing any form of arguementation to go with it.

    He may as well cut and paste. If anything, that is all his contributions amount to. If he can’t tell us his rationale for believing those sources above and beyond the multiple teams of sources that say or indicate otherwise, then he is not engaging in reasoned debate, he is merely shouting his (second hand) opnion in the hope it will be mistaken for informed opinion.

  • 9 ANB // May 3, 2010 at 3:09 pm

    An assertion made without evidence can also be rejected without evidence.

  • 10 Dedj // May 3, 2010 at 5:19 pm

    Unfortunetly, Harold seems to think assertions become evidence depending on who is making them.

    But that’s enough about that. We all know he doesn’t respond to mere mortals like us.

  • 11 ANB // May 3, 2010 at 5:32 pm

    Against such arrogance, even the Gods contend in vain.

  • 12 Harold L Doherty // May 3, 2010 at 6:14 pm

    No offence intended but your hands and wrists must get sore from patting each other on the back in this very, very small club.

    You all comment endlessly about Jenny McCarthy and a few other favorite targets but when other credible names are offered you engage in the usual slew of personal insults.

    You really should get out more.

  • 13 Dedj // May 3, 2010 at 6:39 pm

    Wow, Harold actually deigned to respond.

    Shame he repeated the very same behaviour he was criticised for. Odd that. We weren’t exactly unclear on where he is going wrong.

    Harold – why do you assume people don’t know what you know? Why do you assume that we haven’t heard of these people and their arguements?

    It’s sheer arrogance to assume that people don’t agree with you because they don’t know what you know. Healy et al have certainly not been underreported in the autism media. You have no basis for your assumption.

    You need to start telling us why we should listen to you.

    Second hand cut and pastes simply won’t cut it Harold.

    If you want to go around bad mouthing others without looking like a clueless jerk, then you best start living up to your own standards.

  • 14 Dedj // May 3, 2010 at 6:44 pm

    You can call it patting ourselves on the back if you want Harold, but your repeated demands that people must answer your questions, otherwise they are ignorant know-nothings unlike your special little self, is the height of self-congratulatory egotism.

    This is just like the ‘Smiling and Autism’ debacle all over again.

    You never did get round to providing any scientific evidence for your beliefs back then either.

  • 15 Sullivan // May 4, 2010 at 8:09 am

    in a post about false balance, Mr Doherty calls for false balance.

  • 16 Joseph // May 5, 2010 at 10:47 am

    I am not an anti-vaxxer…
    You mention the usual names but fail to mention Dr. Healy and Dr. Gerberding

    @Harold: You sound like a broken record.

  • 17 SpinProctor // May 5, 2010 at 12:21 pm

    Nobody spins records anymore. Harold sounds like a digital remix of Jenny McCarthy’s greatest hits.

Leave a Comment